A shy girl that hopes senpai will notice her someday. From 1880 to 2018 less than 5 people per year have been born with the first name Anniemay. Annie: B-baka … Hoorah! Annie is one of the most open and optimistic, the-sun'll-come-out-tomorrow type of name, having been celebrated over the years in song (Annie Laurie), comic strip (Little Orphan Annie), folklore (Annie Oakley, born Phoebe), and film (Annie Hall). When was the first name Anniemay first recorded in the United States? See the popularity of the girl's name Annie-May over time, plus its meaning, origin, common sibling names, and more in BabyCenter's Baby Names tool. How unique is the name Anniemay? advertisement 1 Fun Facts about the name Anniemay. Annie May. The name Annie is a girl's name of English origin meaning "grace". The oldest recorded birth by the Social Security Administration for the name Anniemay is Thursday, January 6th, 1898. I love you.